Mortgage Lending to Minorities: Where's The Bias?
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper examines mortgage lending and concludes that studies based on data created by the Boston Fed should be reevaluated. A detailed examination of these data indicates that irregularities in these data, when combined with the most commonly used research methodology, appear to have biased previous research toward a finding of discrimination against minority applicants. When the most severe data irregularities are eliminated, evidence to support a hypothesis of discrimination disappears. The currently fashionable "flexible' underwriting standards of mortgage lenders may have the unintended consequences of increasing defaults for the 'beneficiaries' of these policies.
منابع مشابه
Mortgage Lending Discrimination and Racial Differences in Loan Default
This article analyzes the use of racial differences in loan default to test for mortgage lending discrimination—an approach whose underlying theory has not been carefully explored. The loan approval process creates a selected sample of loans. If mortgage lenders hold minorities to a higher standard, the minority sample should have greater selection bias than the majority sample and so should ex...
متن کاملMortgages, Minorities and Discrimination: A Bank-Specific Approach
The publication of the ‘Fed Boston Study’ drew considerable attention to the long-standing issue of discrimination of minorities in mortgage lending. Federal regulators have since stepped up their efforts to enforce greater compliance of banks with various fair-lending laws. Stengel & Glennon (1999), in their influential paper, offered the industry a statistical methodology that individual bank...
متن کاملFair Lending Analysis of Mortgage Pricing: Does Underwriting Matter?
This paper focuses on potential interaction between the mortgage underwriting and pricing decisions for fair lending analysis of mortgage pricing. We argue that the loan approval or denial decision determines the loan origination population and therefore the underwriting policies might affect the fair lending assessment of the subsequent pricing decisions. The paper also finds that sample selec...
متن کاملNew Evidence on the Relationship between Race and Mortgage Default: the Importance of Credit History Data
&Research staff for help in obtaining and understanding the data, as well as for offering comments and suggestions. Thanks are also due a reviewer of an earlier draft. INTRODUCTION The traditional method for testing for lender discrimination has involved the estimation of a mortgage rejection equation to determine whether there is an independent race effect, after controlling for credit risk fa...
متن کاملQuantifying Discrimination: The Role of Race and Gender in the Awarding of Subprime Mortgage Loans
The recent subprime mortgage crisis has brought to the forefront the possibility of discriminatory lending. Many – including groups like the NAACP – claim that women and minorities were disproportionately awarded subprime rates on their home purchase loans. Using the millions of observations collected by the federal government in 2006 through the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act, this paper explore...
متن کامل